Adrian was admitted to the NSW Bar in 2001 and QLD Bar in 2002. Since that time he has practised in many areas including common law (personal injuries), criminal law, family law, commercial law and administrative law.
Adrian’s common law practice involves advising and appearing for plaintiffs in intentional torts claims, motor accident injury and work injury damages claims and medical negligence claims.
Adrian has a keen interest in intentional torts cases and upholding the liberty of the subject. Over his 25 years of practice at the Bar, he has conducted many intentional torts cases for plaintiffs against both the State of New South Wales and other States and Territories and Commonwealth of Australia, as well as other institutions and authorities. Such cases have included claims for damages for false imprisonment, assault and battery, malicious prosecution, misfeasance in public office and collateral abuse of process.
In 2022, Adrian successfully represented Bill Spedding against the State of New South Wales in a claim for malicious prosecution and collateral abuse of process: Spedding v State of New South Wales [2022] NSWSC 1627. On appeal by the State, the Court of Appeal described the case as the worst case of malicious prosecution proved against the State thus far.
Adrian also possesses considerable experience in judicial review matters pertaining to motor accident and work injury claims. In December 2017, in recognition of his experience in motor accident injury claims, Adrian was appointed as a Claims Assessor under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. In March 2019 he was appointed as a Claims Assessor under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999. His appointments ceased with the commencement of the Personal Injury Commission (PIC). Adrian did not transition into the PIC as he still has a substantial practice representing injured claimants and the President of the Commission quite properly took the view that one cannot be a Member of the PIC and also appear before it.
ADRIAN C. CANCERI
TABLE OF SELECT CASES
|
Name of Case and Citation |
Judicial Officer / Arbitrator / CARS Assessor / Other tribunal Member |
Brief Description of the Nature of the Proceedings |
|
BK v State of New South Wales |
Ward P |
I appeared for BK, an Indigenous client who sought leave to appeal the decision of the District Court of New South Wales rejecting his claim that he had been assaulted and battered by certain members of the New South Wales Police Force. BK was 16 years of age at the time of his alleged assault and battery. I successfully argued that the trial miscarried due to the failure of the trial judge to apply the rules in Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67 and Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298. The matter has been remitted to the District Court for retrial, on the orders of P Ward and Stern JA. Adamson JA would have ordered a judgement for the plaintiff. |
|
R v Mayuran Devakumr (February 2026, unreported) |
Mendes DCJ |
I appeared for the offender who pleaded guilty to commercial supply of a prohibited drug on the Dark Web. I previously secured bail for the client in the Supreme Court of NSW. The matter involved a voluminous amount of electronic evidence. My client was sentenced to a term of imprisonment to be served in the community by way of an intensive correction order. |
|
Harley v State of New South Wales |
Catsanos SC DCJ |
I appeared unled for the plaintiff in a claim arising from a police search of her handbag after an apparent fare-evasion incident. The proceedings required close analysis of consent in an interaction controlled by police, the evidentiary effect of body-worn-camera footage, reasonable grounds under s 21 of the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 (NSW), and Jones v Dunkel submissions. Judgment was given for the plaintiff and an order made for the defendant to pay the plaintiff’s costs as agreed or assessed on an indemnity basis. |
|
Fuller v State of New South Wales |
Waugh SC DCJ |
I appeared unled for the plaintiff in proceedings for false imprisonment, battery and trespass to goods arising from a warrantless search under s 21(1)(d) of the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 (NSW). The case concerned whether police surveillance and intelligence, including a mistaken belief as to the unit entered by the plaintiff, objectively supported reasonable suspicion. The claims were dismissed; contingent damages were assessed at $2,000. |
|
Smith v Blanch |
Kirk JA |
I appeared for a transgender woman who had obtained, on appeal to the District Court, an apprehended personal violence order (APVO) against Ms Smith, a spokesperson for Binary Australia. The matter involved, inter alia, complex issues of statutory construction and constitutional law issues. My client was successful in defending the matter.
|
|
Reyes-Carrion v State of New South Wales (consolidated proceedings) |
Newlinds SC DCJ |
I appeared unled for the plaintiffs across six related proceedings concerning repeated police stops, searches and detentions. The trial involved the proper construction and application of ss 21, 36, 202 and 204A of the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 (NSW), the objective content of “reasonable grounds”, the evidentiary necessity for proving the specific information informing police suspicion, consent in a coercive setting, and compensatory, aggravated and exemplary damages. Several plaintiffs recovered general damages; no aggravated or exemplary damages were awarded. |
|
State of New South Wales v JR; State of New South Wales v Dickens; State of New South Wales v Jensen |
Gleeson JA |
I was led by D Toomey SC for the respondents, having conducted the multi-plaintiff trial unled. The appeal concerned apprehended bias and procedural fairness, reasonable and probable cause and malice in malicious prosecution, misfeasance in public office, the permissible investigation period and “timeouts” under the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 (NSW), the point at which false imprisonment ended after charge and refusal of bail, and compensatory, aggravated and exemplary damages. The Court delivered comprehensive reasons materially recalibrating aspects of the primary liability and damages analysis regarding the claims for false imprisonment. Applications for special leave by JR, Jensen and Dickens were refused with costs on 3 April 2025. |
|
Mr J v State of NSW |
Chen J |
This matter concerned an application for leave to administer interrogatories to a police officer in a malicious prosecution claim. To my knowledge, no such application had previously been made in such a claim. I successfully argued the application. The substantive matter is listed for trial commencing 26 August 2024. |
|
Harry Radley v State of NSW (1 July 2024) |
Newlinds DCJ |
I appeared for the plaintiff who, as a child, was allegedly assaulted and battered and falsely imprisoned by police after running onto the playing field at Allianz Stadium to congratulate his brother who had made his NRL debut for the Sydney Roosters. The matter settled favourably for the plaintiff. |
|
Mark Coughlan v State of NSW NSWDC (1 May 2024) |
Mediated by R Seton |
I represented a plaintiff who sued the State for malicious prosecution. The plaintiff was remanded in custody for several months before the charge against him was withdrawn. The case involved, inter alia, the conduct of a solicitor from the DPP relating to the presentation of the Crown case at a bail hearing. The matter resolved favourably to the plaintiff. |
|
Reeves v State of NSW |
Bell CJ |
I appeared at first instance in the District Court unled with a junior, S Boland, opposing J Sexton SC and J Lee (see below) and was subsequently led in the NSW Court of Appeal by David Hooke SC. The appeal was unsuccessful. Special leave to appeal was refused with costs on 5 September 2024: [2024] HCASL 251. |
|
Cheryl Sparrow & Ors v Northern Local Health District & Anor NSWSC (28 May 2024) |
Mediated by R Seton |
Mediation of a claim for damages for nervous shock caused by the negligence of a public hospital and doctor in misdiagnosing a patient’s illness. Significant liability and quantum issues. |
|
Susan Browne v Dr Devenney & Anor NSWSC (27 May 2024) |
Mediated by |
Mediation of a claim for damages for nervous shock and claim for compensation under the Compensation to Relatives Act, relating to the negligence of a public hospital and medical practitioners causing the death of the plaintiff’s husband. Significant liability and quantum issues at play. |
|
Jeremiah Pangiakaetau v State of NSW NSWDC (14 May 2024) |
Gibson DCJ |
Approval of a settlement of a claim for damages for a child assaulted and battered and falsely imprisoned by police. |
|
Kim Gabriele v State of NSW NSWDC (15 April 2024) |
Cole DCJ |
Claim for damages for assault and battery and false imprisonment committed by police. The matter settled at trial and involved novel issues relating to the power of police to detain a person under domestic violence legislation. |
|
Michael Adams v Sapphire Aluminium Pty Ltd PIC (11 April 2024) |
Member McHugh |
Mediation of a claim for work injury damages. |
|
Janice Edwards v State of NSW NSWDC (4 April 2024) |
Cole DCJ |
Claim for damages for assault and battery and false imprisonment committed by police. The matter settled at trial. |
|
Jake Wiffen v State of NSW NSWDC (3 April 2024) |
Mediated by C Hicks |
Mediation of a claim for damages against the State for serious personal injuries sustained by the plaintiff whilst an inmate at a correctional facility. The plaintiff was violently assaulted by a fellow inmate. Significant issues in respect of liability. |
|
Akaylan Dixon v State of New South Wales NSWDC (15 March 2024) |
Gibson DCJ |
Approval of a settlement of a claim for damages for an Indigenous child assaulted and battered and falsely imprisoned by police. |
|
Naikia Taylor bht Janelle Taylor v Life Without Barriers & Kevin Maher NSWDC (15 March 2024) |
Gibson DCJ |
Approval of a settlement of a claim for damages for an intellectually disabled plaintiff injured by sexual abuse and neglect whilst in care. Significant liability and quantum issues. |
|
Leigh Fraser v State of New South Wales NSWDC (1 March 2024) |
Mediated by C Hicks |
Mediation of a claim for damages false imprisonment. |
|
Daniela Beltrame v State of New South Wales NSWDC (26 February 2024) |
Mediated by C Hicks |
Mediation of a claim for damages for assault and battery and false imprisonment relating to alleged breaches of the COVID public health order. |
|
Kevin Lee v State of New South Wales NSWDC (19 February 2024) |
Mediated by R Seton |
Mediation of a claim for damages for serious physical and psychological injuries sustained by the plaintiff as a result of being assaulted and battered by a police officer. |
|
Sharon Hodge v State of New South Wales NSWDC (12 February 2024) |
Mediated by C Hicks |
Mediation of a claim for damages brought by a climate change protester against police for assault and battery and false imprisonment. |
|
Kalahi Riogi bhnf Samantha Joseph v State of New South Wales NSWDC (12 December 2023) |
Gibson DCJ |
Approval of a settlement of a claim for damages for serious personal injury sustained by a child as a result of a battery committed by police. Liability was strongly contested. |
|
Sega Penu v Exodus Foundation PIC (27 November 2023) |
Mediated by |
Mediation of a claim for work injury damages. Significant liability issues at play. |
|
Shaw v Insurance Australia Group Limited t/as NRMA Insurance |
Rothman J |
This matter involved a judicial review challenge to the decision of the delegate of the President of the Personal Injury Commission of NSW granting an application for the review of a medical assessment. The challenge was successful on the application of the Wednesbury principle, which is typically a difficult principle to invoke. |
|
Erroll Darrell Phillips v Gordian Runoff Insurance & Ors NSWDC (25 October 2023) |
Mediated by M |
Mediation of a claim for damages for personal injury arising out of 3 separate motor accidents. The matter involved complicated issues in respect of causation. |
|
Jake Brennan v Arthur Tsiavous NSWDC (3 October 2023) |
Wilson DCJ |
Approval hearing in relation to the settlement of a claim for damages for a child seriously injured in a motor accident. |
|
McLaughlin v State of NSW |
Russell DCJ |
This was a novel case in that the District Court considered, for the first time, the application of s 46 of the Bail Act 2013 (NSW), and associated provisions, to a claim for false imprisonment. The plaintiff was successful in his claim for false imprisonment and was awarded indemnity costs. The application for leave was successfully defended by D Toomey SC and S Boland. |
|
Azzopardi v Mahajan |
Strathdee DCJ |
In this matter I successfully argued that the Court should exercise its discretion to send the matter back for a further medical assessment under s 62(1)(b) of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (NSW). The end result was that the reassessment resulted in the plaintiff recovering a sum for non-economic loss damages. |
|
State of NSW v Madden |
Bell CJ |
I conducted the trial in this matter in the District Court (leading S Boland) and was led by Dominic Toomey SC in the appeal who successfully argued, inter alia, that the qualified immunity in s 43A did not apply because “injury” in s 3B(1)(a) of the Civil Liability Act included the deprivation of liberty, with the consequence that s 3B(1)(a) was engaged. |
|
Ivan Little-Hales v State of NSW NSWDC (14 August 2023) |
Mediated by C Hicks |
Mediation of a claim for damages for assault and battery, false imprisonment and trespass to land. |
|
Tristan Hockings v State of NSW NSWDC (8 August 2023) |
Mediated by C Hicks |
Mediation of a claim for damages for serious physical and psychological injuries sustained by the plaintiff as a result of being assaulted and battered by a police officer. Significant causation issue in respect of the claim for loss of hearing. |
|
Merlin McKenzie v State of New South Wales NSWDC (3 August 2023) |
Mediated by |
Mediation of a claim for damages for assault and battery, false imprisonment and malicious prosecution relating to alleged breaches of the COVID public health order. |
|
Justin Holtz v RAR Cranes & Multiplex ACTSC (25 July 2023) |
Mediated by K Stott |
Mediation of a claim for damages for nervous shock caused by the death of the plaintiff’s father in an industrial accident. In issue was whether or not the accident causing death was a ‘motor accident’. |
|
Anderson v State of NSW; Perri v State of NSW |
Gleeson JA |
This matter considered whether the actions of police in strip searching two Indigenous boys constituted child sexual abuse for the purpose of s 6A of the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW). The Court of Appeal considered the definition of sexual abuse for the first time and accepted that the determination as to whether the impugned abuse carries a sexual connotation involves an objective assessment of the conduct in question. |
|
Spedding v State of NSW |
Bell CJ |
I conducted the trial in this matter before Harrison J. The matter garnered significant publicity, owing to the subject matter, and was recognised by the Court of Appeal as the worst case of malicious prosecution proved against the State thus far. |
|
Adam Anderson v Dr Simon Nothling NSWSC (5 June 2023) |
Mediated by R Seton |
Mediation of claim for damages for personal injury suffered as a consequence of the negligence of an ophthalmologist. Significant liability and causation issues. |
|
Reeves v State of New South Wales |
Abadee DCJ |
The matter involved a novel claim for false imprisonment based on the plaintiff being taken to an interview room to be interrogated, despite indicating his unwillingness to participate in an interview. The plaintiff was successful in respect of this cause, however the result was overturned on appeal (see above). Special leave to appeal was refused with costs on 5 September 2024: [2024] HCASL 251. |
|
Jack Randall & Ors v State of NSW NSWDC [2023] (not reported on Caselaw) (17-20 April, 18 May 2023) |
Curtis DCJ |
I appeared in the District Court for JR and others in a claim for malicious prosecution and false imprisonment. JR was successful in his claim for malicious prosecution and awarded the sum of $730,000 plus interest. The other plaintiffs were successful in their claims for false imprisonment. The prior criminal trial of the plaintiffs in 2017 attracted significant public interest. All accused were acquitted. The State’s appeal was determined in State of New South Wales v JR; State of New South Wales v Dickens; State of New South Wales v Jensen [2024] NSWCA 308. I appeared for the respondents led by D Toomey SC. Applications for special leave by JR, Jensen and Dickens were refused with costs on 3 April 2025: [2025] HCADisp 83, [2025] HCADisp 84 and [2025] HCADisp 85. |
|
Khaled Merhi v State of NSW & Anor NSWSC (17 May 2023) |
Mediated by R Seton |
The plaintiff claimed damages for assault, battery, false imprisonment and trespass to property. Merhi was initially suspected and quickly cleared of being involved in a plan to commit a terrorist act (the bringing down of a commercial passenger flight). The Commonwealth was represented by Perry Herzfeld SC and the matter was listed for hearing on 28 August 2023. The matter settled favourably for the client. There was significant public interest in the matter. |
|
Chris Rizzo v State of NSW NSWDC (14 March 2023) |
Andronos DCJ |
Matter settled at trial. The matter involved a claim for damages for assault and battery, false imprisonment, malicious prosecution and misfeasance in public office. The matter garnered significant public interest after the events the subject of the claim were captured by a bystander’s mobile phone camera. |
|
Kate Hartcher v State of NSW NSWDC (23 February 2023) |
Mediated by C Hicks |
Mediation of a claim for damages for assault and battery and false imprisonment. The matter attracted significant public interest because of the circumstances (police officer drawing firearm and pointing it at the plaintiff unnecessarily). |
|
Polgampola Abeyratna v Iron Mountain Australia Group PIC (21 February 2023) |
Member McIlwaine |
Mediation of a claim for work injury damages. |
|
Spedding v State of New South Wales |
Harrison J |
Judgment on interest and costs. Indemnity costs awarded. |
|
Madden v The State of New South Wales |
Fitzsimmons DCJ |
Claim by plaintiff for damages against NSW Police for false imprisonment, malicious prosecution and misfeasance in public office. |
|
Temon Tayla v State of NSW NSWDC (12 October 2022) |
Mediated by |
Mediation of a claim for damages for a plaintiff (a child at the time of the relevant event) who was seriously assaulted, battered and maliciously prosecuted by police. |
|
Penelope Pok v Pham Minh Do NSWDC (5 October 2022) |
Gibb DCJ |
Claim for damages for personal injuries sustained by a child in a motor accident. Matter settled at trial. |
|
Hugh Andrew Usher v State of NSW NSWDC (20-21 September 2022) |
Levy DCJ |
Claim for damages for assault, battery and false imprisonment committed by members of the NSW Police Force. Matter settled successfully on second day of trial. |
|
Anderson v State of New South Wales & Anor |
Weber DCJ |
Claim by two Indigenous men who had been strip searched by police as children. The case involved limitation issues, the most important of which was a consideration of whether the claims met the definition of “sexual abuse” in s 6A of the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW). The plaintiffs pursued an application for leave in the Court of Appeal (see above). |
|
Spedding v State of New South Wales |
Harrison J (as he |
This matter attracted significant public interest in that the plaintiff was at one time a suspect in the disappearance of William Tyrell. I was successful in obtaining a judgment for plaintiff in the sum of $1,484,292 plus interest for the torts of malicious prosecution, misfeasance in public office and collateral abuse of process. The State’s appeal in this matter was dismissed (see above). |
|
Flanagan v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd |
Chen J |
This was an application for administrative law relief in respect of the determination of a medical assessor from the PIC. The matter concerned, inter alia, the failure of the medical assessor to apply a section of the medical assessment guidelines not previously considered by the Court. The plaintiff was successful. |
|
Gabriel Allen v State of NSW (District Court, settled shortly before trial on 1 August 2022) |
N/A |
Claim for damages for assault, battery, false imprisonment and malicious prosecution committed by members of the NSW Police Force. |
|
Name of Case and Citation |
Judicial Officer / Arbitrator / CARS Assessor / Other tribunal Member |
Brief Description of the Nature of the Proceedings |
|
Gavin George White v NRMA Insurance (PIC, matter settled shortly before hearing) |
Member Cassidy |
Assessment of damages for personal injuries sustained in a motor accident. |
|
Spedding v State of New South Wales |
Harrison J |
Claim by plaintiff for damages against NSW Police for false imprisonment, malicious prosecution, misfeasance in public office and collateral abuse of process and against the Director of Public Prosecutions for malicious prosecution. Hearing concerning the admissibility of certain portions of the book I catch Killers co-authored by former Detective Inspector Gary Jubelin. |
|
Spedding v State of New South Wales |
Harrison J |
Hearing concerning admissibility of evidence tendered in other proceedings. Consideration of the Harman undertaking. |
|
Spedding v State of New South Wales |
Harrison J |
Application by defendant for leave to rely on the statement of former Detective Inspector Gary Jubelin. |
|
Natascha Rogers v NRMA Insurance (PIC, 8 March 2022) |
Member Stern |
Assessment of damages for serious personal injuries sustained in a motor accident by an NSW Ambulance paramedic whilst on duty. |
|
Loureiro v Mac Aus Unit Pty Ltd |
Gleeson J |
I appeared unled with E Bartley for the plaintiffs on an evidentiary ruling during a commercial trial. The plaintiffs sought to tender a forensic accounting report as summary evidence under s 50 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW). The Court held that the underlying records were neither sufficiently voluminous nor complex and that aspects of the report involved commentary or evaluative judgment rather than true summary evidence. The tender was rejected. |
|
Loureiro v Mac Aus Unit Pty Ltd (No 2) |
Gleeson JA |
Construction and interpretation of loan agreements and consideration of limitation defence. |
|
Mulligan v The Nominal Defendant |
Mcfarlan JA and |
Summons seeking leave to appeal a decision of Wass DCJ in a claim for personal injury damages under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999. |
|
QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd v Griffin |
Schmidt AJ |
Judicial review proceedings commenced by the plaintiff insurer in respect of the assessment of damages of Assessor Stern in a motor accident claim. |
|
Benjamin Williamson v Nine Network Australia Pty Ltd (Mediation before Member Tancred of the Personal Injury Commission, 4 June 2021) |
Member Tancred of |
Mr Williamson was formerly employed by Nine Network as a Senior Camera Operator. He claimed damages for psychiatric injuries sustained during the course of his employment, which involved him being sent to film various events such as the war in Afghanistan and the demise of flight MH17 over Ukraine. Mr Williamson was also tasked to cover the story of an Australian attempting to recover her children in Lebanon. The claim involved complicated issues relating to breach of duty of care and causation of injury. |
|
Brian Frederick Lakin v Silk Contract Logistics Pty Ltd & Anor (District Court 2018/334228, 22-26 March 2021, judgment delivered on 7 April 2022) |
Olsson SC DCJ |
Claim for damages for personal injuries against several defendants (claims against occupiers of premises). Significant liability issues. |
|
Melmeth v State of New South Wales |
Neilson DCJ |
Claim by plaintiff for damages for malicious prosecution. |
|
Findlater v Insurance Australia Limited t/as NRMA Insurance |
Harrison AJ |
Judicial review of a medical assessment of the State Insurance Regulatory Authority of NSW (SIRA). Consideration of an irrelevant matter on the issue of causation of the need for medical treatment. |
|
Ea v Diaconu |
Payne JA, White JA |
I appeared for the appellant who commenced proceedings against the first respondent (an Australian Federal Police Officer) alleging that she had committed the tort of misfeasance in public office by reason of the manner in which she conducted herself while seated in the public gallery of the court room during my client’s criminal trial. The primary judge summarily dismissed my client’s proceedings on the basis that he had failed to identify any public power or duty exercised by the first respondent, this being an element of the tort of misfeasance in public office. The Court of Appeal upheld the appeal finding that the first respondent’s alleged misbehaviour was arguably the exercise of a de facto power, being a capacity, the first respondent had, by virtue of her office, to influence the jury by her reactions to submissions and evidence. |
|
Roberts v Marks |
Ierace J |
Application pursuant to s 55(1)(b) of the Crimes (Appeal and Review) Act 2001 to set aside the convictions of the plaintiff for offences under the Crimes Act 1900 and Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002. |
|
Ea v Diaconu |
R A Hulme J |
See description given in relation to Ea v Diaconu [2020] NSWCA 127. |
|
Hutchinson v State of New South Wales |
Gleeson JA |
I appeared for the appellant. The appeal was brought in relation to the decision of the District Court to dismiss my client’s claim for damages for false imprisonment, assault, battery and malicious prosecution. The events concerned the alleged conduct of several police officers during the 2013 Sydney Mardi Gras parade. |
|
Pratten v State of New South Wales |
Payne JA |
Application for leave to appeal a decision of the District Court concerning my client’s claim for damages for false imprisonment, assault and malicious prosecution against several police officers. |
|
Anna Rose Lambden bhnf Viola Morris v Roads & Maritime Services (District Court of NSW, 22 March 2019) |
Letherbarrow DCJ |
Application for the approval of a settlement of a claim for damages for personal injuries sustained by a child as a consequence of being electrocuted when she stepped onto the metallic lid of a traffic control signal pit located in Haymarket. The traffic control signal pit was situated in the construction zone of the Sydney Light Rail track. |
|
Kerr v Insurance Australia Ltd |
Harrison AJ |
Proceedings for judicial review of a medical assessment carried out under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 and the decision of the Proper Officer of SIRA concerning my client’s application for a review of the medical assessment pursuant to s 63 of the Act. |
|
AAI Limited t/as AAMI v Phillips |
Davies J |
Judicial review of a medical assessment of the Review Panel of SIRA. Consideration of s 58(1)(b) of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 and the test to be applied in determining whether treatment relates to an injury caused by a motor accident. |
|
Williams-Cook v Schloss |
Jarro DCJ |
I appeared unled for the plaintiff in a Queensland District Court motor accident trial in which liability was admitted and quantum contested. The matter required close analysis of causation and credibility in the setting of delayed complaints, prior miscarriages, pregnancy, pre-existing symptoms and disputed economic loss. Judgment was entered for the plaintiff in the sum of $35,708.25. |
|
Gibb-Smith v State of New South Wales |
Neilson DCJ |
Claim for damages for false imprisonment, assault, battery and malicious prosecution against several police officers. The plaintiff was a child at the time of the relevant events. |
|
Dominice v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd |
Basten JA Simpson |
The appeal considered s 63(3) of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 which empowers the Proper Officer of SIRA to refer an application for a review of a medical assessment to the Review Panel, but only if the Proper Officer is satisfied that there is reasonable cause to suspect that the medical assessment was incorrect in a material respect. The Court held, inter alia, that it is the Proper Officer’s satisfaction of the existence of reasonable cause for suspicion that is relevant, not the existence, evaluated by the court, of reasonable cause for suspicion. |
|
Hunter v State of New South Wales |
Leeming JA Simpson |
Application for leave to appeal a decision of the District Court concerning my client’s claim for damages for false imprisonment. The Court of Appeal considered the issue as to whether the plaintiff was required to file a reply at trial alleging that the arresting police officer had failed to effectually exercise the discretion to arrest for a breach of bail, the power to arrest being conferred by s 50 of the Bail Act 1978. |
|
Raad v State of New South Wales |
Dicker SC DCJ |
Claim for damages for false imprisonment, assault and battery and malicious prosecution against several police officers. |
|
Dominice v Allianz Insurance |
Fagan J |
See description in relation to Dominice v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd [2017] NSWCA 171. |
|
Zahed v IAG Ltd t/as NRMA Insurance |
Meagher JA, Leeming |
The appeal concerned the extent of a CARS assessor’s obligation to provide reasons generally and in relation to claims for past and future domestic assistance. |
|
SU v Commonwealth of Australia & Anor; BS v Commonwealth of Australia & Anor |
Hamill J |
Claim for damages for false imprisonment of two Indonesian nationals who were, as children, detained by the defendants in an adult correctional facility. Before being detained in an adult correctional facility, the plaintiffs were in immigration detention. This case concerned the right to “residual liberty”. |
|
David John Francica v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd |
Rothman J |
Judicial review of the certificate and reasons of the medical Review Panel of the Motor Accidents Authority. The case considered, inter alia, whether the Panel asked itself the wrong question in determining the issue of causation of injury. |
|
Rodger v De Gelder |
Macfarlan JA |
Appeal from the decision of Hamill J quashing the certificate and reasons of a medical Review Panel of the Motor Accidents Authority of NSW. Hamill J found that the Review Panel had failed to take into account a relevant consideration, namely the plaintiff’s contemporaneous complaint of pain in his thoracic region and the reasons of Levy DCJ concerning causation of the injury to the thoracic region. The Court of Appeal considered, inter alia, whether a failure to take into account relevant evidence on the issue of causation could amount to a failure to take into account a “relevant consideration” for judicial review purposes. |
|
IAG Ltd t/as NRMA Insurance v Zahed |
R S Hulme AJ |
See description in relation to Zahed v IAG Ltd t/as NRMA Insurance [2016] NSWCA 55. |
|
De Gelder v Rodger (No 2) |
Hamill J |
See description in relation to Rodger v De Gelder (2015) NSWCA 211. |
|
Bugat v Fox |
R S Hulme AJ |
Judicial review of the certificate and reasons of the medical Review Panel of the Motor Accidents Authority of NSW. It was held that the Panel applied the incorrect test of causation by treating the absence of contemporaneous evidence of injury as determinative on the issue of causation. |
|
McIntosh v Zobouian |
R A Hulme J |
Judicial review proceedings of the certificate and reasons of the medical Review Panel of the Motor Accidents Authority of NSW. This case concerned, inter alia, whether the panel applied the principle in Nguyen v Motor Accidents Authority (NSW) [2011] NSWSC 351; (2011) 58 MVR 296 (i.e. whole person impairment does not need to flow from a frank injury to a body part). |
|
Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Francica |
Hall J |
Judicial review of the certificate and reasons of a Medical Assessor of the Motor Accidents Authority of NSW. The Court considered whether the reasons of the Medical Assessor were adequate. |
|
Rodger v De Gelder |
Beazley JA Tobias |
Application for leave to appeal the decision of Levy DCJ not to refer the matter back to CARS for further assessment of damages pursuant to s 111 of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act. The Court considered the terms of s 111(3) (i.e. whether evidence adduced by the insurer “may have materially affected the assessment made by the claims assessor”). |
|
Rodger v De Gelder & Anor |
Beazley JA |
Appeal in relation to the decision of Davies J quashing the decision of the Proper Officer of the Motor Accidents Authority of NSW to refer a matter for further medical assessment pursuant to s 62 of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act. The Court held, inter alia, that by participating in the further medical assessment the plaintiff had not waived or abandoned his right to seek prerogative relief regarding the decision of the Proper Officer to refer the matter for further medical assessment. Accordingly, it was held that the plaintiff was not debarred on discretionary grounds from obtaining prerogative relief because he had elected to engage in the further assessment. |
|
Glover-Chambers v Motor Accidents Authority of NSW & Anor |
McCallum J |
Judicial review proceedings concerning a decision of the Proper Officer of the Motor Accidents Authority of NSW under s 62 of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act (i.e. referral for further medical assessment). The Court considered whether the Proper Officer applied the correct test under s 62. |
|
Goodman v The Motor Accidents Authority of NSW & Anor |
Hoeben J |
Judicial review proceedings of a decision of the Motor Accidents Authority of NSW to revoke a referral to a particular medical assessor and appoint a new medical assessor. |
|
Garcia v Motor Accidents Authority of NSW |
Rothman J |
Judicial review of the certificate and reasons of a Medical Assessor of the Motor Accidents Authority of NSW. Importantly, the Court considered the meaning of the phrase “additional relevant information about the injury” in s 62(1) of the Motor Accidents Compensation Act. |
|
Safi v Zhao |
Hungerford ADCJ |
I appeared unled for the plaintiff in a motor accident damages trial where liability was admitted and the central issue was the effect of prior accidents and pre-existing symptoms. The Court accepted that the subject accident temporarily aggravated the plaintiff’s pre-existing condition and awarded $20,250.70. |
|
Presidential Security Services of Australia Pty Ltd v Clinton Joseph Brilley |
Allsop P |
Appeal from a decision of O’Toole DCJ awarding damages to my client who had been shot by a security guard whilst breaking into a suburban bowling club. The Court considered, inter alia, the rules of attribution of criminal responsibility to a company. |
|
Educational and Computing Software Pty Ltd v Kumar |
Harrison J |
I appeared unled for the defendant and cross-claimant in Supreme Court proceedings concerning a licence to occupy premises, residential tenancy legislation, estoppel and a cross-claim for debt. The plaintiff’s amended claim was dismissed, a declaration was made that the plaintiff was indebted to the defendant in the sum of $312,700.07, and costs were ordered in the defendant’s favour. |
|
Berou v Consumer, Trader and Tenancy Tribunal and Anor |
Harrison AsJ |
I appeared unled for the plaintiff in proceedings seeking prerogative relief from a decision of the Consumer, Trader and Tenancy Tribunal. The challenge alleged denial of procedural fairness and error of law in the application of the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW) and the Tribunal’s statutory powers. The appeal and amended summons were dismissed. |
|
McGregor v Henry |
White J |
I appeared unled for the defendants on an application concerning possession of land, equitable relief, estoppel and the continued operation of interlocutory undertakings and restraint orders. The defendants were released from their undertaking, the possession and restraint orders were discharged, and the plaintiffs were ordered to pay the defendants’ costs. |
|
Santos v Santos |
Master Macready |
I appeared unled for the plaintiff in Family Provision Act proceedings brought by a former wife after the deceased severed a joint tenancy shortly before death and his interest passed to his second wife. The matter involved a small estate, sale of the only substantial asset, the outstanding mortgage and the apportionment of costs. |